David Ross (dyvyd) wrote,
David Ross

Hilbert's 24th problem

     How does one get the job done with the maximum impact and the minimum number of words?  How does one know whether a short sentence is more complex than a longer, somehow boring sentence?  Does mere factual understanding have anything at all to do with the experience of profundity or art, or is the writer's craft more tied to a manufactured, or induced psychological feeling, an emotional experience that substitutes for actual understanding?   We obviously do not get huge rewards (most of us) from reading a good mathematical theorem.  It fails to satisfy  us, I think, for all the wrong reasons, and puts into suspicion those literary efforts which, like fatty foods, seem to nourish our very souls. This is somewhat unfair, since most of us are not highly trained to read a theorem richly and deeply.  At least I imagine such a reading is possible, say by Roger Penrose.  But for the rest of us, I keep coming back to the idea that the quintessential reading experience is this: "Boy, we are really on to something now!"  The less well defined, the more powerful this feeling often is.
     So the author's work is largely legerdemain.  It is work nonetheless to envision, make consistent, propose, reveal, control dynamically, and then exit gracefully from a constructed universe that is more rewarding than the fragments of reality we individually perceive.  Every novel is in some sense a "Reality Reconfigured 2.0" simulation for our "thinking meat" brains to ingest
     The very least we can derive from Hilbert is his insistence on defining a problem to be solved, whether with words or mathematics.  If the proof of the fiction be incomplete, we will never judge the work as "whole."
Tags: writers and writing

  • Eco. Eco.

    Eco's The Prague Cemetery is a dismal book whose protagonist is a proud anti-semite, a forger of documents, a murderer, a despiser of women and…

  • Saragossa 4

    What I seem to be pointing toward is that the Manuscript Found in Saragossa is that rare polymath literary attempt to encompass the full range of…

  • Saragossa 3

    It is curious that Potocki would write such a book of tales if his motive were informed solely by a love of the Arabian Nights. His book contains a…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment